5 Best Supper Clubs in Southern Wisconsin

5 Best Supper Clubs in Southern Wisconsin

Best Supper Clubs in Southern Wisconsin

When it comes to dining out in Southern Wisconsin, supper clubs offer a unique and charming experience. These establishments are known for their warm hospitality, cozy ambiance, and delicious home-cooked meals. Whether you're a local or visiting the area, here are some of the best supper clubs in Southern Wisconsin that you don't want to miss.

1. The Old Fashioned

The Old Fashioned, located in Madison, is a popular supper club that celebrates the classic Wisconsin supper club tradition. Their menu features comfort foods like fried cheese curds, bratwurst, and Friday night fish fry. Make sure to try their signature old fashioned cocktail, a staple in Wisconsin.

With its rustic decor and friendly atmosphere, The Old Fashioned provides an authentic supper club experience. The walls are adorned with vintage beer signs, and the old-fashioned bar is a great place to enjoy a drink before your meal. Don't forget to start your meal with a bowl of their homemade beer cheese soup, a local favorite.

One of the reasons why The Old Fashioned stands out is their commitment to showcasing local Wisconsin ingredients. They source their meats, cheeses, and produce from nearby farms, ensuring that every dish is fresh and flavorful. From their juicy butter burger to their creamy mac and cheese, each bite is a taste of Wisconsin's culinary heritage.

2. Ishnala Supper Club

Nestled in the beautiful Mirror Lake State Park near Wisconsin Dells, Ishnala Supper Club offers breathtaking views of the surrounding nature. Known for their prime rib and seafood dishes, Ishnala is a favorite among locals and tourists alike. Don't forget to indulge in their famous grasshopper cocktail while enjoying the stunning sunset.

One of the unique features of Ishnala Supper Club is its architecture. The building is constructed with native materials, including cedar logs and fieldstone. The massive stone fireplace in the center of the dining room adds to the cozy and intimate atmosphere. Make sure to make a reservation in advance, as this popular spot fills up quickly.

At Ishnala, you can expect top-notch service and an extensive menu that caters to all tastes. Their prime rib is cooked to perfection, with a juicy and tender texture that will leave you wanting more. If you're a seafood lover, their lobster tail and jumbo shrimp are must-try options. For a truly indulgent experience, pair your meal with a glass of their hand-selected wine.

3. Buckhorn Supper Club

Located on the shores of Lake Koshkonong, the Buckhorn Supper Club in Milton is a hidden gem in Southern Wisconsin. This family-owned establishment has been serving up mouthwatering steaks, seafood, and homemade desserts for over 80 years. The rustic atmosphere and friendly staff will make you feel right at home.

What sets Buckhorn Supper Club apart is their commitment to using locally sourced ingredients. From the fresh catch of the day to the seasonal vegetables, every dish is prepared with the finest ingredients. Don't miss their famous Friday night fish fry, where you can enjoy a variety of fish options, including perch, walleye, and cod.

When dining at Buckhorn Supper Club, you'll be treated like family. The cozy fireplace, wooden beams, and lakefront views create a welcoming and relaxing ambiance. Be sure to save room for dessert, as their homemade pies and cakes are the perfect way to end your meal on a sweet note.

4. The 5 O'Clock Club

In Pewaukee, The 5 O'Clock Club is a supper club with a modern twist. Their menu offers a fusion of traditional supper club dishes and contemporary cuisine. From their famous prime rib to their seafood pasta, every dish is prepared with care and creativity. The 5 O'Clock Club also boasts an extensive wine list to complement your meal.

The 5 O'Clock Club prides itself on its attention to detail and culinary innovation. The chefs here are constantly experimenting with new flavors and techniques to create unique and memorable dishes. Whether you're in the mood for a classic supper club meal or want to try something new, The 5 O'Clock Club has something for everyone.

One of the highlights of dining at The 5 O'Clock Club is their elegant and sophisticated atmosphere. The dim lighting, plush seating, and live music create a refined ambiance that is perfect for a romantic date night or a special celebration. Pair your meal with a glass of wine from their extensive selection, and you're in for a memorable dining experience.

5. The Hobnob

Located in Racine, The Hobnob is a historic supper club that has been operating since 1954. With its retro decor and nostalgic charm, this place will transport you back in time. From their mouthwatering steaks to their Friday night fish fry, The Hobnob is a beloved destination for locals craving classic supper club fare.

When you step into The Hobnob, you'll feel like you've entered a time capsule. The vintage booths, dim lighting, and live piano music create an atmosphere that harkens back to a bygone era. Their menu features all the traditional supper club favorites, including succulent prime rib, crispy fried chicken, and delectable shrimp cocktail.

One of the highlights of dining at The Hobnob is their attentive and friendly service. The staff here goes above and beyond to ensure that every guest has a memorable experience. Don't forget to save room for their famous brandy ice, a refreshing and iconic Wisconsin dessert.

If you find yourself in Southern Wisconsin, be sure to visit these incredible supper clubs. Whether you're looking for a romantic dinner, a gathering with friends, or simply want to experience the rich culinary heritage of the region, these supper clubs will surely leave you satisfied.

Back to blog